Listen Listening The First Offender Prostitution Program is like traffic school, except the goal is to educate people who have been arrested for soliciting prostitutes. There is a photo of herpes. There is chlamydia. There is gonorrhea.
Motivated by their Christian faith, a group of white women set out to offer the immigrant women a path out of slavery and sex trafficking and, ideally, into what they viewed as good Christian marriages. It would become the longest re-entry blackout in the history of the space program. Until we can begin to support rights for migrant workers and craft policies to support their needs to work, we are stuck in a quagmire that attracts, indystry rescues "innocent victims. The mission home was always run on a Undergroune, and so the Ameers mom were put to work to try to help support the house and support themselves as well. In other instances, the missionary workers, usually someone like Cameron plus a Chinese worker at the home, would raid a brothel, or would hear that a girl was in distress. I need three times that many to keep up. She was apparently an absolutely brilliant woman.
Naughty short skirts porn. Related Stories
We luckily found coverage behind the bench, snapped some photos, heard Gallery nude lesbian girl walkies, and ran like hell. Undsrground captors will ensure the women never pay off their debts, by tacking on fees for food, clothing or rent. Normally all exploring is done in the shadows of the night, shrouded frnacisco darkness and anonymity. Recruiters fill the want ads in papers and San francisco underground sex industry Internet, targeting vulnerable young women with fake job offers for waitresses, models and invustry in America. Jasmine Abuslin, who used the alias Celeste Guap San francisco underground sex industry working as a prostitute, claims to have had sexual relations with as many as 30 officers from six Bay Area law enforcement agencies, including San Francisco and Oakland. We only allotted one hour thanks to the whole fear-of-drowning thingand I used every last second. In terms of profits, it's on a path to overtake drug and arms trafficking," said Barry Tangan Immigration and Customs Enforcement attache with the U. And to think the needles were the least of my worries -- the scent literally brought a grown man to his knees. She had a knack for finding porn stashes in the woods and would take the The center in spokane across town to pay 25 cents to watch peep shows at an franfisco bookstore. But Dixie has devoted her entire life to a subject that is usually talked about only in hushed tones: francisck sex stories. Traffickers fly the women to Ineustry or Mexico, and walk or drive them into California. Iconic producer of Gangbang squad previews 'Godfather' dies at Five percent reported being arrested for not having sex with a police officer while eight percent reported being arrested after having sex with a police officer. Tim Hettrich of the San Francisco police vice unit. Thanks to The Bold Italic Editors.
Send comments on this series to Chronicle photographer Deanne Fitzmaurice at dfitzmaurice sfchronicle.
- A night at Bawdy Storytelling.
- I've been taking photos for as long as I can remember, and have been a bender of rules for even longer.
- In San Francisco and across the country prostitution remains illegal, with the exception of some rural Nevada counties.
- Send comments on this series to Chronicle photographer Deanne Fitzmaurice at dfitzmaurice sfchronicle.
Send comments on this series to Chronicle photographer Deanne Fitzmaurice at dfitzmaurice sfchronicle. Chronicle photo by Deanne Fitzmaurice Send comments on this series to Chronicle.
Many of San Francisco's Asian massage parlors -- long an established part of the city's sexually permissive culture -- have degenerated into something much more sinister: international sex slave shops. San Francisco's liberal attitude toward sex, the city's history of arresting prostitutes instead of pimps, and its large immigrant population have made it one of the top American cities for international sex traffickers to do business undetected, according to Donna Hughes , a national expert on sex trafficking at the University of Rhode Island.
Because sex trafficking is so far underground, the number of victims in the United States and worldwide is not known, and the statistics vary wildly. The most often cited numbers come from the U. State Department, which estimates that , to , people are trafficked for forced labor and sex worldwide each year -- and that 80 percent are women and girls. Most trafficked females, the department says, are exploited in commercial sex outlets.
Relying on research from the Central Intelligence Agency , the State Department estimates there are 14, to 17, human trafficking victims brought into the United States each year -- but does not quantify how many of those are sex victims. Some advocacy groups place the number of U. The CIA won't divulge its research methods, but based its figures on 1, sources, including law enforcement data, government data, academic research, international reports and newspaper stories.
Women trafficked for the sex industry are predominantly from Southeast Asia, the former Soviet Union and South America -- lured to the United States by promises of lucrative jobs as models or hostesses, only to be sold to brothels, strip clubs and outcall services and extorted into working off thousands of dollars in surprise travel debts to their new "owners. Federal investigators say that even those who come to the United States with the idea of working as high-society call girls cannot imagine the captivity and the degrading workload they face.
In terms of profits, it's on a path to overtake drug and arms trafficking," said Barry Tang , an Immigration and Customs Enforcement attache with the U. Department of Homeland Security in South Korea. The United States is among the top three destination countries for sex traffickers, along with Japan and Australia. It's an underground world, but in more than interviews with federal agents, experts and sex trafficking victims in California and South Korea, a picture emerges about how international traffickers buy and sell women between Asia and the West Coast.
Overseas, the trafficker is usually a woman. She recruits from clubs, bars, colleges, pool halls and restaurants, said Deputy Special Agent Mark F. Wollman , who oversees San Francisco for U. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Recruiters fill the want ads in papers and the Internet, targeting vulnerable young women with fake job offers for waitresses, models and hostesses in America. Traffickers fly the women to Canada or Mexico, and walk or drive them into California. In Canada, they slip through Indian reservations off-limits to the U.
Border Patrol , often at night, and sometimes along snow-packed trails. In Mexico, the traffickers lead the women over the same treacherous desert paths worn down by migrants heading to "El Norte" for work.
More women come through airport customs in San Francisco and Los Angeles, using fake passports and student or tourist visas made for them by their traffickers. It's relatively easy for traffickers to evade authorities at the checkpoints -- land, air or sea -- because women still don't realize at that point that they are being tricked. Once in California, the women are taken most often to Los Angeles or San Francisco, where they are hidden inside homes, massage parlors, apartments and basements, only to learn that the job offer was just a ploy.
Typically they are locked inside their place of business, forced to have sex with as many as a dozen men a day. Sometimes victims are forced to live in the brothel, too, where five or six "co-workers" are crammed into one room.
Their "owners" confiscate their travel documents until the women pay off exorbitant sums. Often captors will ensure the women never pay off their debts, by tacking on fees for food, clothing or rent. Some fine the women for displeasing customers, being late to work, fighting or a host of other possible transgressions.
Yuki, 25, who fears for her safety and only gave her first name to The Chronicle during an interview in Seoul, said she was trafficked from South Korea to a karaoke bar in Inglewood Los Angeles County , where she was assured that she would simply be serving drinks to men. Sex slaves who work in massage parlors and bars are often locked in their place of business by double security doors, monitored by surveillance cameras and only let outside under the guard of crooked taxi drivers who ferry them to their next sex appointment.
Women report being beaten, raped and starved by their keepers. Both women eventually escaped their captors and now live as shut-ins in Seoul, spending their time on the phone or the Internet or watching TV, too afraid to go outside and cross paths with someone from the network that trafficked them.
They are scared because sex trafficking rings are often run by criminal organizations that aren't afraid to use violence to protect the billions they generate.
Tim Hettrich of the San Francisco police vice unit. I have nine people working on this. I need three times that many to keep up. There are at least 90 massage parlors in San Francisco where sex is for sale, according to the online sex Web site myredbook. The site has been around since and has more than 55, reviews of Northern California sex workers.
It is used by johns, yet is also a main monitoring tool for law enforcement. On average, there are about eight women working in a massage parlor, police say. That would mean more than Asian sex masseuses working in San Francisco, based on 90 illicit parlors listed on sex Web sites and on police interviews. But the scope of sex trafficking in San Francisco is much larger -- women are also forced to work as escorts, outcall girls, erotic dancers and street prostitutes.
Women are also placed in "AAMPs" -- Asian apartment massage parlors -- which are little more than apartments rented by traffickers who staff them with one or two sex workers. Business is done by word of mouth, and only customers approved by the owner are allowed in. Police in Livermore, Concord, San Mateo and Santa Clara have all found residential Asian brothels in their neighborhoods in and She can watch men come and go at all hours of the day to a massage parlor across the street from her office.
No one is going after the johns. The city may even be unwittingly contributing to the problem. Thirty-seven of the erotic massage parlors on My Redbook's list have massage permits issued to them through the San Francisco Department of Public Health.
When asked about the city giving permits to illegal massage parlors, Johnson Ojo, principal environmental health inspector for San Francisco, said part of the problem has to do with a big backlog that was created when jurisdiction over massage parlors was moved from the Police Department to the Department of Public Health in If we find anything suggesting trafficking, we talk to police.
When told by The Chronicle of the scores of erotic massage parlors with city permits, Newsom said, "We aren't doing our job. We should take these Internet lists and go down them one by one. In July, Newsom waited with city inspectors one afternoon outside Sophia's Spa, an alleged brothel in an alley between an ultra-modern cocktail lounge and a sex shop on Geary Street.
A decoy, an Asian police officer in jeans and a T-shirt, stood in view of the security camera over Sophia's front door and pressed the buzzer. The metal security door opened. He duct-taped the lock so Newsom, the inspectors, police, a social worker and a reporter could get in. It was a rude awakening for the half-dozen men inside, one of whom was in the middle of a sex act with a masseuse on the lobby couch.
While sex between adults on the lobby couch indicates that Sophia's is not a holistic massage establishment, it's not a crime unless the police see money change hands. Inspectors cited Sophia's for using the premises as a living quarters, for inadequate ventilation, for improperly attired employees and for using a bed instead of a massage table in one room -- enough to land the owner in a permit revocation hearing before an administrative judge.
Although Sophia's has a massage parlor license from the Department of Public Health, the establishment is emblematic of a booming Asian sex-trafficking business that operates with near impunity in the city, Newsom said.
It thrives because it's so hard to prosecute -- the same women who are needed on the stand to help win cases are the ones who are being threatened into silence by their captors, said Heidi Rummel, a former federal prosecutor with the sex trafficking unit in Los Angeles. They wonder: If the door was open, why didn't she just run?
Sex traffickers who get caught are rarely convicted of sex trafficking -- and they know it. It's a frustrating cat-and-mouse game for federal investigators and prosecutors, who spend a year or more keeping a sex slavery network under surveillance, and then none of the women held in captivity is willing to testify.
But she is more afraid of her traffickers than us. Women are scared for good reason. Those who have become witnesses have been burned with acid, have disappeared, or have had their homes ransacked and their families harmed or threatened in their home countries, said Dong Shim Kim , head counselor at Du Re Bang My Sister's Place , a shelter for sex trafficking victims in South Korea.
Newsom admits that city inspectors alone can't shut the illicit massage parlors down, but he says City Hall is starting to regulate an underground industry that it's never inspected before. Newsom put together a team of health and safety inspectors in summer , shortly after California's largest sex-trafficking bust -- Operation Gilded Cage -- made it clear that a lot of the sex in the massage parlors was not consensual.
City officials were taken aback that all masseuses removed from the 10 parlors in San Francisco were Korean, just like the 45 others arrested statewide on charges of running an international sex trafficking ring.
The federal case is pending. Since the federal raid, just one of the alleged sex parlors targeted in Gilded Cage has been shut down by the city. Golden Dragon Spa was ordered to surrender its massage permit on Aug. Two others targeted in the federal raid closed when their buildings were sold. The city attorney's office has prosecuted several other massage parlors, but the punishments have been "sorely disappointing," said Julian Potter, Newsom's public policy chief.
In a three-part series, The Chronicle will tell the story of You Mi Kim, a debt-ridden college student from South Korea who reveals how she was trafficked into sexual slavery in California. This year, the U. Here's what's been damaged so far in Kincade, Bay Area fires. Yuki, a sex trafficking victim, escaped from a brothel in Inglewood and spends most of her time hiding indoors in South Korea.
Chronicle photo by Deanne Fitzmaurice Send comments on this series to Chronicle photographer Deanne Fitzmaurice at dfitzmaurice sfchronicle. Chronicle photo by Deanne Fitzmaurice Send comments on this series to Chronicle Caption Close. Image 1 of Back to Gallery. Related Stories. Most Popular. Dissent erupts at Facebook over stance on political ads. Blue Bottle moving coffee roasting out of Bay Area. Three killed after Amtrak train strikes vehicle in Richmond. Getty Fire forces evacuations of over 10, buildings in LA area.
Iconic producer of 'Chinatown,' 'Godfather' dies at United Airlines making tiny regional jets much roomier.
Sex Trafficking v. Some of the tunnels below have taken years of searching, tons of liquid courage, and a few tips from underground legend Sierra Hartman. Dixie stepped onstage to introduce the show. Iconic producer of 'Chinatown,' 'Godfather' dies at One of the massage businesses that the men were standing outside of in late was Queens Health Center. I've been taking photos for as long as I can remember, and have been a bender of rules for even longer. For 10 years, stories of kink, sex positivity and the sexual underground have been told on her stage.
San francisco underground sex industry. The Bold Italic
How Sex Workers Made San Francisco Safer for Everyone – Next City
In the s, San Francisco, and the American West generally, was a hotbed of anti-Chinese sentiment. Spurred by racism, exacerbated by the economic uncertainty of an ongoing recession, the xenophobia manifested itself in discriminatory legislation and violent physical intimidation against Chinese men and women.
Anti-miscegenation laws and restrictive policies that prohibited Chinese women from immigrating to the U. Motivated by their Christian faith, a group of white women set out to offer the immigrant women a path out of slavery and sex trafficking and, ideally, into what they viewed as good Christian marriages.
In , they founded the Occidental Board Presbyterian Mission House and, for the next six decades, more than 2, women passed through the doors of the brick building at Sacramento Street, San Francisco. A revelatory history of the trafficking of young Asian girls that flourished in San Francisco during the first hundred years of Chinese immigration and an in-depth look at the "safe house" that became a refuge for those seeking their freedom.
Slavery was technically outlawed in the United States with the passage of the 13th Amendment, but another type of slavery exploded in California in the years following. It was what we now describe as the trafficking of women from China to the west coast. Those women were literally sold at auction in the s and the s on the wharf of San Francisco.
Later on, those sales started to go underground, but the trafficking of women for sex slavery, for forced prostitution, continued into the early 20th century. It continues today, but not in the way you would see hundreds of women coming off ships and being sold. What role did the U. Was San Francisco's government or the police force doing anything to curb the trafficking?
The immigration policies played a very dramatic role and led to the very striking imbalance in genders. The Page Act, which barred most Chinese and Asian women from entering the United States, was an effort to try to stop so-called prostitutes from entering the country.
In the s there were 10 Chinese men for every one Chinese woman [living in San Francisco]. The Chinese Exclusion Act [banned all labor immigrants from China and] only allowed a certain class of Chinese person, including merchants and students, to come into the United States. This immigration policy backfired in that [the immigration of] Chinese women was restricted, but there was a huge demand for Chinese women from men who were very far away from their families.
So criminal elements seized on this opportunity and recognized that it could become very lucrative to bring women into the country for sex. Enormous corruption amongst the police force and city government through the latter half of the 19th century actively helped the trafficking and the traffickers used it to their advantage.
What was the Occidental Mission House? What motivated the women who founded the home? This story begins with a visiting missionary from China and was describing the condition of Chinese girls and women there.
They soon realized that instead of looking to try to help girls and women in China, they should look closer to home in that the girls and women that were literally on their doorsteps were suffering very greatly and that it was an incredible opportunity to try to reach out to them. They decided to exercise power in a way that was open to them, which was to found a home, a charitable enterprise.
The purpose was to provide refuge to girls and women who had been trafficked into sex slavery or prostitution. It was also, of course, to try to share their Christian faith with them.
What started as a trickle in women taking up the missionaries on their offer, grew exponentially. By the s, the home was filled with 40, 50, 60 girls and women living there at any one time. Often, some would stay for a day or two, some would stay for a few months, some would stay for years and go to work in the home themselves.
Your book primarily focuses on Donaldina Cameron, the superintendent of the home. What challenges did she face? Over the course of the decades that she ran the home, Cameron encountered a lot of resistance, both from white policeman and white city officials as well as the criminal Tong [Chinese secret society] members who were involved in the trafficking of women from China to San Francisco.
Some of the women heard about the home, ironically, from their traffickers who spread rumors about it. In other instances, the missionary workers, usually someone like Cameron plus a Chinese worker at the home, would raid a brothel, or would hear that a girl was in distress.
Often accompanied by a policeman or some other authority figure, they would find a way in and find a girl who was in distress.
Their lives were very regulated. There was a set breakfast time, there were prayers. All the girls were required to do chores around the house, to sweep up, to cook. In the later years classes taught them how to sew. There were English classes, there were Chinese classes. There was an opportunity for some sort of an education, and that was a very striking thing because Chinese girls in San Francisco were not often formally educated. They would go church at least once a week.
The mission home was always run on a shoestring, and so the girls were put to work to try to help support the house and support themselves as well. My impression, having read everything I could find in terms of Dolly's official writings to her Board, church records, as well as her private writings in her diaries, was that she was a very pragmatic woman. She was very motivated by her own faith, but I did not get the sense that she ever was angry or disappointed if other people did not share or find her faith.
The mission home did report the number of baptisms, for example, but often it was three baptisms in a year and they would have more than women pass through the home.
As time went on, particularly in the s and s from there, it really was evolving towards more of a social services home. I just think they were very clear that not all of the girls who went passing through there would share their faith. Marriage was seen as the ultimate goal at the Mission House. What were those partnerships like?
The mission home became a de facto marriage bureau. The gender imbalance not only in the West, but across the country, amongst Chinese men was still in place. So word got out that there were Chinese women in the mission home. It was very much part of the late Victorian ethos amongst the mission home workers that their goal was to create a family, and ideally a good, Christian family.
They would set criteria for men who came asking for the hands of some of the women who lived at the home. I mean they were hoping that they, too, were Christians, and that they had stable jobs, and that their requests were not just a ruse to get these women back into a forced prostitution.
This book is not a book primarily about the white superintendents of the home—it is primarily about the women who found their freedom at the home. Which ones really stuck with you? The book begins and ends with one of the most famous crime cases of the s on the West Coast. A group of trafficked women found the courage, with the help of the mission home workers, to testify against their traffickers. Those stories are astonishing, and as a historian I was very lucky to have just a wealth of material to try to document their journey.
The woman that I begin the book with [Jeung Gwai Ying]—she was with child and she had her child during the period that she was in this legal battle. I so admired the sheer courage it took to do something like that, to testify against people who were a lot more powerful than she was.
The other one that is just so searing to me was a case of Yamada Waka, an extraordinary Japanese woman who came to the home right at the turn of the 20th century. She had been trafficked and forced into prostitution in Seattle. She made her way down to San Francisco, escaping that situation with the help of a Japanese journalist.
When she got to San Francisco, almost unbelievably the journalist tried to force her back into prostitution. She fled to the mission home. The most notable stories are ones where the women chose to go to the home and to use it as a launching pad for their own freedom.
She found her education at the mission home. She probably was not literate before she got there. She was apparently an absolutely brilliant woman. She found her husband through classes at the mission home.
Then he and she returned to Japan and she became a very, very well-known feminist writer in Japan. Not only that, but she opened up a home of her own in Japan modeled on the one in the mission home to try to help other women. Her story is very much one of agency, of education and of empowerment.
Her description of her experience of being forced into prostitution was absolutely searing. Tien Fuh Wu was one of the women who stayed at the home and assisted Dolly in her mission. Can you describe their partnership? She was very much, I would argue, an equal partner to Dolly.
In some ways, my book can be seen as a story of an extraordinary friendship between two women who were so different from each other and came from such different places. Tien Wu had been sold by her father in China to pay his gambling debts, and she was sent to San Francisco to work as a mui tsai , a child servant.
One pattern of that type of servitude was that once those girls came of age, they would sometimes end up as prostitutes. Tien Wu found herself working in a brothel in San Francisco's Chinatown, and then was sold from there to two women. They badly mistreated her and burned her. A neighbor, somebody in Chinatown, sent a note to the mission home alerting them of the condition of this poor girl, so a rescue was staged by the missionary workers to get her.
She was brought to the mission home. At first, she didn't like Dolly at all and resented Dolly as a newcomer, because Tien had arrived 15 months before Dolly started as a sewing teacher in the s. Tien was an intelligent young woman who had the benefit of a sponsor who paid for her education, so she went back east for school and then made the choice to come back to the mission home in San Francisco and work as Dolly's aide.
One of the most touching parts of their story is the fact that they spent their whole lives together—neither married, neither had children. It's a story of radical empathy, of a friendship between two vastly different people coming together for the same aim: to help other women. I would say that this is an early MeToo story.
This is a story of women standing up for other women. This is a feminist story. This is a story of an early effort to fight human trafficking, to fight modern slavery. This incredibly small group of [the founding] women who had virtually no power in their lives.
They couldn't vote. This is one way that they could exercise power, to set up a home.